|
21 JUL 2004 |
|
Dialogue ultra-portable Flybook (Part
I) |
|
In business it pays to be
well-connected.
For road warriors it becomes even more
important to be able to have access to the Internet and other devices
via all available means.
And you want it in the smallest
possible package.
Let me introduce you to a close to
ideal travelling companion, the Flybook from Dialogue.
If you’ve been attracted to the likes
of FlipStart, the OQO or any other ultra-portable notebook, you owe it
to yourself to have a good look at the tablet-style Flybook.
You expect it to have WiFi and
Bluetooth, but add a SIM card slot for GPRS (there’s even a CDMA
model), a CF / PC card slot, 2 FireWire ports and suddenly you have
an ultra-capable machine.
Did you say you want it in
Ferrari-red?
|
|

The Flybook on top of
the Toshiba TE2100 with iPAQ 2210 and Asus MyPal A730
|
|
The timing could not have been more
perfect: 2 weeks before going on a long trip to Europe, the Flybook
landed on my doorstep.
I had not looked forward to toting my
hernia-causing Toshiba laptop around so the prospect of just having this
super compact, lightweight and very well-connected companion along
became very appealing.
Just like the looks of the Flybook:
very attractive – even in its more conventional silver rather than the
other colour options.
The differences between my trusty
TE2100 (brand-new and very capable a year ago) and the Flybook are
amazing.
Here’s a quick compare. For roughly
the same purchase costs the Flybook has the following extra features:
WiFi, BT, SIM card slot, 2 Firewire, 2 USB2.0, double battery life, half
the weight, half the size, touch screen.
Missing are the legacy ports
(finally!), a built-in optical drive (not a deal-breaker and, once
the applications have all been installed, the lack of such is an
advantage on the road) and the cooling fan (hooray!)
Power from the Transmeta
Crusoe TM-5800 engine (1 GHz) is a bit less than
the Toshiba’s (1.8GHz) with a 512K L2 Cache but
memory is the same as my upgraded laptop at 512MB. The hard drive is a
decent 40GB in the 2.5” format.
Where the two
machines differ is of course also in the display area and technology.
The Flybook has
probably the largest screen in the ultra-compact category: an 8.9"
wide-view, 16:9 display with an LTPS screen.
This Low Temperature
Poly Silicon-based TFT screen gives a higher aperture ratio and improves
screen brightness significantly.
Resolution on the
Flybook itself is Wide-XGA (1024x600) at its max and the maximum
external resolution is1800x1440 (32bit).
|

Carry box (Front) |

Carry box (Back) |
|
Sometimes we have no choice in who
we travel with. But what we travel with is a bit easier these
days.
Few laptops will turn heads. This
sub-sub-compact will.
The teeny form factor, the bright
display, the twist & turn screen all help to draw attention to it.
I didn’t select the Ferrari-red for a
good reason. Not only do I not have a matching vehicle but I just want
to get some work done on a plane!
So the Carrera Silver suits me better
than the Dino Red, Sprite Blue, or the Cobra Black.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
|
|
Ah, the choices in how we connect to
the net or other devices!
You name it and the Flybook will suck
in the data you need via any type of network, even through a SIM card.
It will sit comfortably next to your
cappuccino without taking up most of the table.
What will happen when someone, in
their eagerness to have a good look at your companion, knocks over your
coffee?
Yes, it’s spill proof, water proof to
five fathoms and can withstand the searing heat in the kitchen! Just
kidding, of course!
Actually, the screen is not very
smudge proof as I found out.
And that’s only because I like to work
the screen with my fingers instead of whipping out the stylus. Bad
habit!
|
 |

SIM card slot next to Power button |
|
The main attraction of the Flybook is
its size.
Small is beautiful and smaller plus
smarter is a most seductive combination.
Have a look at the comparison photos
with my Toshiba TE2100 laptop and the iPAQ 2210.
Is it a replacement for either?
Depends on your needs.
Personally, I have good use for all
three but there are times when I can take only one and the Flybook is
the perfect fit for most of these occasions.
The small size surprised me somewhat
when I took it out of the carry box.
I was also surprised at the heavier
than expected “feel” of the unit.
Mind you, at a little over 1kg the
Flybook cannot possibly be classified as heavy but the typical PDA
weighs less than 200g and the typical laptop generally is 10 times as
heavy.
The Flybook seems to be just right for
its size.
|

3 on 1: Toshiba, Flybook, Asus |
 |
|
The Flybook has not only just about
all the features and options you’d want in an ultra-portable but also
comes very complete in the box.
Starting with a nice touch (which is
not all that self-evident when items are being shipped to a place like
Australia) the power cord is a proper Australian one.
No need to search for adaptors!
The actual power adaptor is half the
size and weight of my Toshiba’s but lacked a pouch for travel whereas
the Flybook itself does have an adequate, soft slip cover.
Not a big deal as small pouches can be
found everywhere but one of my previous laptops did get scratched by an
uncovered power plug…
The battery is separately packed and
clicks into place securely with 2 latches.
This particular model has Windows XP
Pro pre-installed and 3 recovery CDs plus the Certificate of
Authenticity from Microsoft.
There are also a couple of straps and
a video-out cable, a warranty card, Quick Start Guide and most
importantly, a good manual.
Most of the manual also resides on the
hard drive so you don’t have to travel with the hard copy manual.
|
|

|
|
Have a look at all the ventilation
holes in the back!
Most of them actually are ports of
some sort, I think…J
There are, of course, a couple of
ventilation louvres to keep the Transmeta cool.
It gets warm to the touch but never
hot so the lack of a power-hungry and noisy fan is not a problem.
Here are the ports and slots around
the perimeter:
-
2 FireWire 1394 ports
-
2 USB 2.0
-
1 LAN (RJ-45)
-
1 PSTN (RJ-11)
-
1 PC Card (PCMCIA Type II)
-
1 mini VGA
-
1 Video-Out
-
1 pair of earphone/Mic
-
1 Built-in WiFi antenna
-
1 Shared Bluetooth antenna
-
1 Built-in WAN antenna
-
1 External wireless WAN antenna connection socket
|
 |
|
You could get a fair few hours out of
the Flybook if you’re judicious with power use.
I like the display setting on full
bright with the chip cranking at full speed and the HDD spinning faster
than a gyro.
That eats up a lot of juice.
In that configuration the Flybook can
perform well over three hours and when used with power saving functions
your endurance is quite decent.
It takes about as long to charge the
battery as it does to discharge when everything is on: some three hours.
More about battery performance in Part
II.
|
|

|
|
On this small keyboard the track point
is positioned above the function keys to the right.
This is quite a comfortable place for
using the device with 2 mouse keys next to it.
I would never have expected another
set of mouse keys on a computer of such small size but the Flybook
sports 2 more keys on the left!
Of course, you’d miss the scroll
wheel, but wait! What’s next to that track point? A PAN button.
Aha! Here’s your scroll
function and, what’s more, it will also allow you to scroll sideways
with the track point! Clever.
And the mouse buttons are also
backlit…
All that choice and yet, for most
interactions you’d probably want to use the stylus on the touch screen.
In the manual it says the Flybook has
a “palm-rejection” type panel, meaning you can lean on it with your
palms while writing on the touch screen.
When you want to use the Flybook in
the traditional sense you’d be pleased to know that the keys are not too
small.
I typed a few paragraphs without ever
hitting the wrong keys (this says nothing about
my real typing skills, which are fairly basic…)
|
 |
 |
|
A heavy laptop can easily become a
pain to lug around.
Tablet PCs are usually much lighter
and the Flybook, which –strictly speaking – is not a Tablet PC running
Tablet PC software, yet it has most of the attractive functions of such.
It can be folded over so that the keyboard is covered and the touch
screen will be able to recognise your handwriting – unless you’re a
medical doctor who writes in hieroglyphs only…
Well, even the medicos will benefit
from this tablet medication: if the Flybook doesn’t make heads or tails
from their scribbling, they have a chance to correct themselves.
We will have a good look at the
built-in handwriting recognition program in Part II.
|
 |
 |
|
-
Surprisingly, with all the communication methods on the
Flybook, one is missing: IrDA infrared. Maybe it is considered legacy
too, being rather slow but it can be a reliable standby to talk to
your phone or PDA (which, of course, the
Flybook is supposed to replace…)
-
The Flybook has a couple of magnetic latches to keep
the two halves together when used in tablet form or in the closed
position. Stronger magnets would have done the job better but a more
secure latching mechanism is welcome too.
-
I’d like to see a couple of LEDs on the outside of the
unit to indicate charging and when it has finished. This is fairly
important as there’s no way to tell, short of turning the Flybook on.
-
There is a caution in the manual about the need to have
the screen at an upright angle first before rotating it for tablet
mode and vice versa. Otherwise damage might be done to the hinge and
the cables inside. If this is such an important issue (and knowing
that most folks don’t read the manual first) I would want to see
some Caution stickers on the Flybook with an illustration. The best
place would be a permanent sticker on the bottom of the unit.
|
|

|
|
If you’re looking for an excellent
travel companion, I would suggest the Flybook should be part of your
entourage.
It’s a near-perfect blend of features,
power and size.
And it has the design and refinement
of class.
Don’t leave home without it.
|
|
Our Highly
Recommended rating is also based on the Flybook’s pricing.
Keeping in mind
that you always pay a premium for laptop technology vs standard computer
components, is the Flybook good value?
Only you can be
the final arbiter of that but we think it is.
This particular
Flybook model as tested with WiFi, Bluetooth and GPRS, has a MSRP
(Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price)
of USD 1999.
Other models will
vary slightly in price.
What are the available models
and options?
·
A33iS :
WiFi
·
A33iSb :
WiFi plus Bluetooth
·
A33iG-tri-b : WiFi, Bluetooth and tri-band GPRS
Options :
·
Memory :
256 / 512 MB
·
HDD : 30
/ 40 / 60 GB
·
OS : XP
Home / Pro
Optional accessories :
·
External
DVD Combo Drive (USB 2.0 link)
·
Bluetooth
GPS device
·
Car
adapter (Power adapter)
Availability will
vary at the moment but the Flybook should generally be available shortly
as the distribution channels are put into place.
For more
information: visit the official Flybook site at:
www.dialogue.com.tw .
Another
interesting site can be found here:
www.flybook.com
|
|
 |
|
|
|
We’ll have an extensive report on
connectivity as experienced with the Flybook.
We’ll be testing every wireless mode.
We’ll give you the nitty-gritty on speed and battery usage in the
various modes.
This is where the number crunching
happens.
Expect graphs and many more photos.
Also: how does the handwriting
recognition measure up?
We have a look at screen and battery
calibration as well.
We’ll check out if we can find more
information on an apparently unique docking
solution which would give you a decent desktop machine as well as
"grab-and-go" functionality.
And finally, we’ll take it up in our
cockpit and check it out with some great navigation programs.
As you may be aware from some of my
previous reviews I have a special interest in aviation navigation
software.
In fact, our sister site,
www.PocketPCReviews.net started out as a direct result of a review I
did for Australian Flying on Control Vision’s AnywhereMap program for
the iPAQ.
Now you’ll find out if the Flybook is
just a nice marketing name or whether it could serve very well as a
navigation panel in an aircraft and really live up to its name! |
|
|
|
|
Processor
|
- Transmeta Crusoe
TM-5800, clock rate:1GHz
- 64K L1 Instruction Cache; 64K L1 Data Cache
- 512K L2 Write-back Cache
- Built-in NorthBridge to support DDR/SDR/PCI interface
- LongRun Technology to extend Battery usage
- Support full SMM(System Management Mode) |
|
Chipset
|
- ALi 1535+
|
|
Graphic
Chipset |
- ATi Radeon
Mobility high performance low power chipset
- Built-in 16MB VRAM
- Support VGA-out and Video-out
- Support DirectXR@9.0 |
|
Main Memory
|
- 512MB DDR |
|
BIOS and
Flash |
- Phoenix FB
BIOS/512KB |
|
Display
|
- 8.9"
wide-view 16:9 display
- LTPS technology
- 1024 x 600 (Wide-XGA) high resolutions
- Highest color to 32-bit
- Touch Panel overlaid for full screen touch control |
|
External
Display |
- XGA (1024 x
768) (highest to 32-bit color)
- SXGA (1280×1024)(highest to 32-bit color)
- Highest resolutions to 1800 x 1440 (highest to 32-bit color)
|
|
External
Video |
- NTSC/PAL
(Production selection) |
|
PC Card
Interface |
- Support
PCMCIA Cardbus Type-I/III |
|
Hard Disk
|
- 2.5" Ultra
DMA 66/100; 40 GB |
|
Bluetooth
(Option) |
- Built-in Bluetooth
Version 1.1
- Antenna : Built-in |
|
Wireless WAN
(Option) |
- Built-in
GPRS
- Frequency : Tri Band ( 900 / 1800 / 1900 MHz )
- Antenna : Built-in |
|
Wireless
LAN(WiFi) |
- Built-in
802.11b Wireless LAN function
- Antenna : Built-in |
|
Wired
connection |
- Built-in
Modem (56K) (RJ-11)
- Built-in LAN (10/100Mbps) (RJ-45) |
|
LED
|
Num Lock /
Cap Lock / Power / Battery / Hard Disk / Wireless WAN connection /
Bluetooth/ WiFi |
|
I/O
|
- One mini-VGA
- One Video-Out
- Two USB 2.0
- Two 1394 Firewire
- One LAN (RJ-45)
- One PSTN(RJ-11)
- One PCMCIA Type-II Slot
- One pair of earphone/Mic
- Built-in WiFi antenna
- Shared Bluetooth antenna
- Built-in WAN antenna
- One external wireless WAN antenna connection socket |
|
Audio
|
- AC 97;
built-in two speakers (stereo) |
|
Keyboard
|
- 80-key
standard keyboard |
|
Fast Keys
|
- Two sets of
Mouse Emulation buttons
- Direction/Confirm Knob (Trackpoint)
- Hot Keys |
|
Power
|
- Support
ACPI for Power On/Off, STR, STD and power management. |
|
Battery
|
- 3-cell
Li-Ion rechargeable battery
- Built-in very-low cut-off/Overcharge/Over-Temp/Over-Current
protection;
- Fastest charging time : 2 hours;
- User swappable |
|
Operating
System |
- Microsoft®
Windows® XP Home or Professional Edition |
|
Security
|
- BIOS/Power
On/Hard Disk user name and password |
|
Mechanical
and
Dimensions |
- Clam shell
and tablet convertible styles
- Landscape/Portrait display
- Dimensions:235 x 155 x 31 (mm)
- Weight around 1230g |
|
External
Power |
- 100~240V /
50-60 Hz |
 |